AP Calculus AB/BC · Unit 4 · Topic 4.5
Solving Related Rates Problems
Model, differentiate, substitute instantaneous data, solve, and interpret a requested rate.
1. Topic Focus
Interpret derivatives as rates in context, connect motion quantities, solve related-rate models, linearize, and evaluate indeterminate limits.
This topic: Model, differentiate, substitute instantaneous data, solve, and interpret a requested rate.
2. Key Relationship
Read every symbol with its domain, direction, units, and hypotheses before applying the relationship.
3. Visual Connection
4. Worked Example
For an expanding circle, dA/dt=2πr·dr/dt.
Write the governing relationship first, carry out the algebra cleanly, and finish with a sentence that answers the mathematical question.
5. Concept Development
1. Decode the Prompt before Calculating
Underline every changing quantity, instantaneous value, given rate, and requested rate. Translate verbal directions into signed derivatives:
| Phrase | Typical derivative translation |
|---|---|
| increasing at \(k\) | \(dq/dt=k\) |
| decreasing at \(k\) | \(dq/dt=-k\) |
| moving away from a reference point | positive distance rate |
| moving toward a reference point | negative distance rate |
| fixed length, height, or volume | the corresponding derivative is zero |
Record units immediately; they help distinguish a value from a rate.
2. The Full Solution Pipeline
- Draw and label a diagram when geometry is involved.
- Define changing variables as functions of time.
- List known values, signed rates, and the requested rate.
- Write one equation relating the changing quantities.
- Differentiate the equation with respect to time.
- Use the original equation to find missing instantaneous values.
- Substitute values and rates into the differentiated equation.
- Solve and state the answer with sign, units, and context.
3. A Diagram Is a Snapshot, Not a Frozen Model
A diagram usually represents the system at the requested instant. Labels such as \(x(t)\), \(y(t)\), and \(r(t)\) remain variable even if the prompt later specifies \(x=5\) or \(r=3\). Fixed dimensions may be labeled with constants. Mark right angles, corresponding sides, and the direction of motion.
4. Choose the Smallest Useful Set of Variables
Define only quantities needed to connect the given and requested rates. Extra variables create extra derivatives. For a plane at constant altitude, use horizontal distance and line-of-sight distance; the fixed altitude can remain a constant. For a conical tank, similar triangles may eliminate radius before differentiation.
5. Match the Situation to a Relationship
| Problem family | Useful relationship |
|---|---|
| ladder, line of sight, perpendicular travel | \(x^2+y^2=z^2\) |
| circle or sphere | \(A=\pi r^2\), \(V=\frac43\pi r^3\) |
| cylinder or cone | \(V=\pi r^2h\), \(V=\frac13\pi r^2h\) |
| shadows or conical containers | similar-triangle proportions |
| angle of elevation | \(\tan\theta=\text{opposite}/\text{adjacent}\) |
| changing rectangle | \(A=\ell w\) |
6. Apply the Correct Differentiation Rule
Related-rates equations frequently require more than the power rule:
Every changing factor must contribute its derivative.
7. Substitute Values Only after Differentiation
Instantaneous values describe one moment, whereas the model must remain valid through nearby moments for a rate to exist. Substituting \(x=5\) before differentiating incorrectly makes \(x\) constant. Keep variables symbolic until the rate relationship has been formed.
8. Recover Missing Instantaneous Values
Use the original relationship, not the differentiated one, to find an unstated length or angle value. A 13-foot ladder with base 5 feet from the wall has height
Choose the physically meaningful root: dimensions and distances are nonnegative.
9. Right-Triangle Distance Problems
When \(x^2+y^2=z^2\), decide which side is fixed and which sides change. If all three can change, differentiation gives
A fixed hypotenuse makes \(dz/dt=0\). For two objects moving perpendicularly, both leg rates may be nonzero.
10. Similar Triangles Remove Extra Variables
In a conical tank or shadow problem, identify corresponding sides and write a proportion. If a cone maintains \(r/h=k\), substitute \(r=kh\) into its volume formula before differentiating. This leaves one changing dimension instead of two unrelated-looking rates.
11. Shadow Problems Contain Two Different Lengths
Let \(x\) be the person's distance from the light, \(y\) the shadow length, and \(z=x+y\) the distance from the light to the shadow tip. The prompt may ask for \(dy/dt\) or \(dz/dt\); these are different rates. Translate the requested motion before solving.
12. Angle Problems Use Radians
For an angle of elevation, a tangent relationship often avoids the hypotenuse:
Differentiate with respect to time and include \(d\theta/dt\). Angular rates from calculus are measured in radians per unit time. If one distance is fixed, its derivative is zero.
13. Multiple Input Rates Can Compete
When several dimensions change, retain every product-rule term. For \(A=\ell w\), an increasing length and decreasing width can make area increase, decrease, or remain momentarily constant. The net sign is determined only after both contributions are combined.
14. Verify the Final Result
- Sign: Does it agree with the chosen direction and physical motion?
- Units: Does a length, area, volume, or angle rate have the correct dimensions?
- Magnitude: Is the result plausible relative to the given rates and geometry?
- Instant: Did you use values from the requested moment?
- Question: Did you solve for the requested derivative rather than a nearby quantity?
15. Common AP Solution Errors
- Using a diagram but never defining its variables.
- Dropping chain-rule or product-rule factors.
- Confusing a decreasing rate with a positive speed.
- Failing to use similar triangles before differentiating a cone or shadow model.
- Substituting instantaneous values too early.
- Using degrees instead of radians for \(d\theta/dt\).
- Finding the shadow-length rate when the problem asks for the tip rate.
- Providing correct algebra without a contextual conclusion and units.
6. Detailed Worked Example and Error Check
Example 1: Sliding ladder. A 13-foot ladder rests against a wall. Let \(x\) be the base's distance from the wall and \(y\) the top's height. Then
When \(x=5\), the original equation gives \(y=12\). If \(dx/dt=2\) feet per second,
The ladder top slides downward at \(5/6\) foot per second.
Example 2: Inflating sphere. A spherical balloon receives air at \(dV/dt=72\pi\) cubic centimeters per second. Since
when \(r=3\) centimeters,
Example 3: Water in a similar conical tank. A cone maintains \(r/h=1/3\), so \(r=h/3\). Eliminate radius from the volume equation:
If water enters at \(dV/dt=4\pi\) cubic centimeters per second, then
At \(h=3\) centimeters, \(4\pi=\pi\,dh/dt\), so \(\boxed{dh/dt=4\text{ cm/s}}\).
Example 4: Person and shadow tip. A 6-foot person walks away from a 12-foot lamp at 4 feet per second. Let \(x\) be the person's distance from the lamp and \(y\) the shadow length. Similar triangles give
Thus \(dy/dt=dx/dt=4\) feet per second. The shadow tip is \(z=x+y\), so
The shadow length grows at 4 feet per second, while the tip moves away from the lamp at 8 feet per second.
Example 5: Camera angle of elevation. A camera is 500 feet from a launch point. A rocket rises vertically at \(dh/dt=200\) feet per second. Let \(\theta\) be the camera's angle of elevation:
When \(h=500\), \(\tan\theta=1\), so \(\sec^2\theta=2\). Therefore
7. AP Reasoning Routine
Name variables and units, write the relationship before differentiating, substitute values at the correct time, and interpret the sign in context.
- Identify the representation and requested quantity.
- State the rule or theorem and verify its conditions.
- Keep exact values until the final requested approximation.
- Interpret sign, units, interval, and context.
Solve each related-rates problem with defined variables, a differentiated relationship, units, and a contextual conclusion.
(a) A 10-foot ladder has base distance \(x\) and height \(y\). The base moves away from the wall at 2 feet per second. Find \(dy/dt\) when \(x=6\) feet.
(b) A sphere's volume increases at \(100\pi\) cubic centimeters per second. Find \(dr/dt\) when \(r=5\) centimeters.
(c) A conical tank maintains \(r=h/2\). Water enters at \(12\pi\) cubic centimeters per second. Find \(dh/dt\) when \(h=4\) centimeters.
(d) A 6-foot person walks away from a 15-foot lamp at 3 feet per second. Find both the shadow-length rate and the rate at which the shadow tip moves away from the lamp.
(e) A camera is 300 feet from a launch point. A balloon rises at 60 feet per second. Find the angle-of-elevation rate when the balloon is 300 feet high.
(f) Two cyclists leave the same point on perpendicular roads. At one instant they are 6 and 8 miles from the start and moving away at 3 and 4 miles per hour. How fast is the distance between them changing?
(g) Explain why instantaneous length values must be substituted after differentiating even when the requested moment is clearly specified.
(h) Give one sign check and one unit check for the answer in part (a).
Check the solution
In part (a), \(x^2+y^2=100\), so \(y=8\) when \(x=6\). From \(x\,dx/dt+y\,dy/dt=0\), \(dy/dt=-6(2)/8=-3/2\) feet per second; the top moves downward. In part (b), \(dV/dt=4\pi r^2\,dr/dt\), so \(100\pi=4\pi(25)\,dr/dt\) and \(dr/dt=1\) centimeter per second. In part (c), \(V=\frac13\pi(h/2)^2h=\pi h^3/12\), so \(dV/dt=(\pi h^2/4)\,dh/dt\). At \(h=4\), \(12\pi=4\pi\,dh/dt\), giving \(dh/dt=3\) centimeters per second. In part (d), similar triangles give \(15/(x+y)=6/y\), so \(9y=6x\) and \(dy/dt=(2/3)(3)=2\) feet per second. Since \(z=x+y\), the tip rate is \(dz/dt=3+2=5\) feet per second. In part (e), \(\tan\theta=h/300\), so \(\sec^2\theta\,d\theta/dt=(1/300)dh/dt\). At \(h=300\), \(\sec^2\theta=2\), giving \(d\theta/dt=0.1\) radian per second. In part (f), \(x^2+y^2=z^2\), so \(z=10\) and \(z\,dz/dt=x\,dx/dt+y\,dy/dt=6(3)+8(4)=50\); hence \(dz/dt=5\) miles per hour. In part (g), those values hold only at one instant; early substitution falsely turns changing quantities into constants and removes their derivatives. In part (h), the top height should decrease, so \(dy/dt\) should be negative, and a height rate must have feet-per-second units.